Hudson Valley Parent

HVP - April 2014

Issue link:

Contents of this Issue


Page 9 of 46

10 Hudson Valley Parent n April 2014 this shift toward informa- tional texts as doing away with fiction; however, it seems clear that students learn best from a balanced curriculum. Students should learn how to identify the plot structure in a literary text and how to unpack the main argument or thesis of an informational text—and it should be up to teachers to determine what texts are appropriate for instruction, based on students' interests and needs. Careful, intentional implementa- tion of informational text instruction is necessary — no single approach works for every classroom. Here are some key points to consider: Choice Students' choices matter. As adults, we devour texts of our own choosing: in any given week, I'll en- gage with texts on topics from cur- riculum development and education policy to vintage knitwear patterns and do-it-yourself home repairs. This skill we take for granted as adults — to locate, sort, and orga- nize information on specific subjects — begins with making choices about texts as young children. Classrooms need a variety of informational text choices that fill the spectrum of stu- dents' interests. Level While interest about a topic can motivate a reader to engage with a text above their independent read- ing level, a text that is too difficult Dear Kiersten, Why is there such an emphasis on reading nonfiction in the Common Core? My child has never been much of a reader, and I'm worried she's going to associate reading with "work" in- stead of discovering new imaginative worlds through fiction. The authors of the Common Core (CC) believe that nonfiction, or informational, texts hold the key to success in college and beyond: "To be ready for college, workforce training, and life in a technological society, students need the ability to gather, comprehend, evaluate, syn- thesize, and report on information and ideas." Whether we agree or not, it's undeniable that as technology grows, so does the need to read: the amount of digital text and number of screens we encounter on a daily basis make reading for information a vital skill. But how is this interpreted in the curriculum, and at what expense? While the CC offers a logical expla- nation for focusing on informational texts, its implementation lacks clarity. The CC calls for a 50-50 balance in literary and informational text instruction in 4th grade, and a 30-70 balance, respectively, in 12th grade. Some schools have interpreted can shut down the inquiry process. Classroom library collections must contain books that vary in level of text complexity. Varied structure Not all informational texts are created equal: some tell stories, while others relay information fact by fact. Exposure to a variety of informational texts — both narrative and non-narrative — broadens the understanding and appeal of nonfiction texts. Not just ELA Teaching literacy is not just the English Language Arts teacher's job — it's everyone's. Students should actively engage with informational texts during content instruction in social studies and science, too, thus leaving plenty of room for fiction in the ELA curriculum. Having more informational texts in classrooms isn't, I think, a completely horrible idea; it's how and why those texts are used that makes all the difference. In the end, students' needs and interests—not a prescribed curriculum—should drive literacy instruction. Kiersten Greene, PhD, is an assis- tant professor of literacy education at SUNY New Paltz. Do you have a question about your child's home- work? Email your Common Core @ Home questions to our editor at KIERSTEN GREEN English Language Arts Common Core @ Home Answers from Common Core experts Part Two of a continuing series On the web: Our math expert answers the question: "What is compensation method? How do we subtract in the new Common Core?" Visit

Articles in this issue

Links on this page

Archives of this issue

view archives of Hudson Valley Parent - HVP - April 2014